Today, we would be discussing the features of two Shure microphones – Shure PG58 Vs SM58. If you know anything about microphones, then you know Shure is a force to be reckoned in the industry.
At the end of this review, you would have enough information to help you decide which microphone is the better option for you. This also means that the article will be as detailed as possible. As a result, you have yourself a lengthy article.
However, if you do not have the time to go over all the details here, make sure you check out the next three sections.
In these sections, you’ll find relevant information in bite-sized portions. That way, you can easily learn enough to influence your decision when getting either of these microphones.
Table of Contents
Shure PG58 Vs SM58 – Comparison Overview
What are the Differences Between the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58?
The major difference between the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58 is down the frequency response, the impedance, weight, and the versions available.
“What are the Differences Between the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58”
Contrary to what you might think, in terms of features, these two microphones are very similar as you’ll see in the comparison table below.
However, as stated above, there is a difference in weight. The PG58 has a bit more overall weight to it, even though the SM58 is the stronger of the two.
Which is better with handling noise: Shure PG58 versus Shure SM58?
The SM58 is a lot better with features that help it deal with noise. On the contrary, the noise handling of the PG58 is not impressive. This is not to rule out the PG58, as it has a better and clearer mid-range than the SM58. However, this isn’t such a huge factor considering that the SM58 can easily be EQ’d to resolve that.
“Which is better with handling noise: Shure PG58 versus Shure SM58”
What are the Similarities Between the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58?
The Shure PG58 and Shure SM58 are very similar. They are both dynamic microphones, have a cardioid polar pattern, and similar overall aesthetics.
“What are the Similarities Between the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58”
For instance, because of these similarities, they share all the benefits and shortcomings of dynamic microphones.
Furthermore, they both have a cardioid polar pattern. As a result, these microphones can pick up sound best from the front, good enough from the sides, and not at all from behind. You’ll need to keep this in mind when you’re positioning these microphones.
They also have the same overall aesthetic with the same shape, color options, and even build quality.
What Is the Cost To Performance Ratio of the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58?
The SM58 costs about double the price of the PG58. However, the PG58 is way past half as good as the SM58. Therefore, the PG58 is a better economic deal. The PG58 cannot be said to be in the same class as the SM58, however, the price is a very fair bargain compared to the SM58.
“What Is the Cost To Performance Ratio of the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58”
If you’re not a beginner, you would notice things like the handling noise, the extra weight, and the higher impedance of the more affordable PG58. Now is that something you want to accept so you can save a few bucks?
The decision is entirely up to you.
Shure PG58 Vs SM58 – Comparison Table
Shure PG58 | Shure SM58 | |
| Frequency Response | 60 – 15,000 Hertz | 50 – 15,000 Hertz |
| Impedance | 300 Ohms | 150 Ohms |
| Built-in On/Off Switch | Available in all versions | Available in only one version |
| Weight | 321g | 298g |
| Versions Available | PG58-QTRPG58-XLRPG58PG58BTS | SM58-LCSM58-CNSM58S |
- With a bass rolloff and brightened midrange, it has a frequency response that is ideal for vocals.
- Comes with an inbuilt pop filter and spherical wind.
- To handle noise and wind intrusion, it has a pneumatic shock-mount system.
- Has a well designed cardioid pickup pattern that reduces background noise and isolates sounds from the front.
- With a bass rolloff and brightened midrange, it has a frequency response that is ideal for vocals.
- Comes with an inbuilt pop filter and spherical wind.
- To handle noise and wind intrusion, it has a pneumatic shock-mount system.
- Has a well designed cardioid pickup pattern that reduces background noise and isolates sounds from the front.
What Scenario Is the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58 Best Suited For?
Shure PG58 | Shure SM58 |
| This microphone works very well for any kind of speaking. If you run a podcast, conduct interviews, render poetry, or carry out other speaking activities, this microphone is great for you. Because of its clear and bright mid-tones, it’s better than the Shure SM58 for speaking. Also, with this microphone, you don’t have to start readjusting the EQ to get the device sounding properly. | This microphone is great for live performances. However, This is especially if you’ll be performing without a microphone stand. Unlike the PG58 that would pick up shakes or movements, on the other hand, this microphone is great at handling noise and offers much better sound, even when you shake it. |
| Because of the cardioid polar pattern, it is great for multiple use. Two or three people can conveniently use this device. | This microphone has a built-in pop filter. As a result, it is slightly better at handling plosives. However, using an external pop-filter will be a lot better. |
Before we go on, here’s a quick video review comparing both microphones.
Video: MIC WARS | Shure PG58 vs. Shure SM58
What are the Features Common to Both the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58?
Some of the features common to both the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58 include the Type, Cardioid polar pattern, Case design, Connector, and Accessories.
“What are the Features Common to Both the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58”
Type – Dynamic
Both devices are dynamic microphones. Compared to condenser microphones, dynamic microphones do not make use of phantom power. Rather, they have coils that amplify sounds picked up by the microphone’s diaphragm.
As opposed to condenser microphones, because dynamic mics do not have an external source: phantom power, the output produced is not as loud as the condenser microphone. This means that for recording something that very quiet, a condenser microphone will be better.
On the contrary, if you need to record something as loud as snare drums, cymbals, or a person with big vocals, then a dynamic microphone will be better.
Especially for live performances, dynamic microphones are preferred by most musicians.
For those who opt for the dynamic microphone, there is also the benefit of cost. This is considering that dynamic microphones do not need an external power source. This makes them considerably more affordable. You can even plug it directly into your sound system which is fine.
Durability is another edge dynamic microphones have. These devices usually have a very solid build. In this regard, the Shure brand is even exceptional. As a result, even after a couple of drops, their microphones are able to function well for a long time.
If you’re still unsure about which microphone you want to get, we suggest you watch this video below. The video explains the difference between the two microphone types with a sound test for each of them.
Video: Dynamic vs Condenser Microphones, What’s the Difference?
Cardioid Polar Pattern
Another important thing to note about both microphones is that they have a cardioid polar pattern.
What is a polar pattern?
A polar pattern is a shape used to describe the areas around the microphone that it would pick up sounds.
“What is a polar pattern”
Both of these microphones have a cardioid polar pattern. This is a heart-shaped curve. In our opinion, it’s more like an upside-down heart shape, something like the popular “Ace of Spades”.
As a result of this carefully constructed polar pattern, you are guaranteed an impressive sound from the front, good sounds from the sides, and nothing from behind.
Basically, any sound source around the 180-degree mark will be picked up by the microphone. Anything more than that will be rejected.
If you are trying to mic about two or three people with the same microphone, this is excellent. Even if you’re amplifying just one person’s voice, it gives the person some freedom and opportunity to wiggle.
However, if you’re going to be performing live with instruments and other singers with you on stage, you might have a slight problem. This is because the microphone is likely to pick-up unwanted sounds from the other musicians and performers.
Well, it’s not all doom and gloom for live performances. This is because you can make the most of the situation. All you need do is place your monitor behind the microphone, directly in front of the singer. This way, the microphone doesn’t pick-up any feedback, and also allows the singer to get feedback clearly.
If you want to visibly see the pickup pattern of a cardioid microphone, watch the quick demonstration below. It’ll help you to fully understand where you need to place your microphone for the best sound.
Video: Cardioid Microphone Polar Pattern (Part 3 of 6)
Case Design
Both the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58 microphones have great case designs. The former has a die-cast metal handle, matte-black finish, hardened silver color, and a spherical steel mesh grille. The SM58 is very similar with a dark-gray, enamel-painted, die-cast metal with a matte finish. It also has a silver-colored and spherical steel mesh grille as well.
More than the appealing design, the durability and sheer strength of the case is one of a kind. Although the PG58 is considered an entry-level microphone, its durability isn’t up for questioning.
Both microphones are strongly built, allowing you to use them for a very long time.
Shure claims that every one of these microphones in the market has passed through a series of drop tests.
Connector
Many microphones, including the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58, makes use of the standard three-pin audio connector. This connector is also known as the XLR. There are other microphones that use different connectors such as the TRRS and USB connectors.
However, most, if not all dynamic microphones have slots for XLR connectors. This is great because you can use the same connector for these new microphones.
Accessories
After observing a good number of microphones, we noticed that many brands offer pretty standard accessories. The same can be said about these two microphones. After purchase, you get a stand clip and a carrying pouch at least.
The stand clip is what allows you to connect the microphone to a microphone stand. The carrying pouch on the other hand allows you to carry the microphone, clip, and your cables comfortably.
Shure PG58 Vs SM58 – Features Unique To Each Microphone
In this section, we would be discussing the features unique to either of these two microphones.
What are the Features Unique to the Shure PG58?
Especially when compared to the SM58, the uniqueness of the Shure PG58 is down to its frequency response which is about 60 – 15,000 hertz, the impedance which is 300 ohms, and the versions available.
Frequency Response – 60 – 15,000 (Hertz)
Frequency response refers to the range of frequencies that your microphone can pick up. So, this microphone can only pick up sounds with the range of 60 – 15,000 Hertz.
The frequency response of this microphone is pretty decent. In fact, the Shure SM58 only goes 10 frequencies lower than this. Looking at the price difference, this is really good.
Except you are recording sounds with very low frequencies, this frequency response is alright.
Impedance — 300 Ohms
The impedance refers to the resistance in an AC voltage. Especially when compared to the Shure SM58, this is one area the PG58 is disadvantaged.
For the most part, you won’t be able to notice the difference between a microphone with 300 impedance, and one with 150 impedance. You will only begin to notice it when you’re using a very long cable.
With long cables, the higher the impedance, the more likely the device starts to lose some of the top-end of your sound. So, if you’re using this across a very large stage, you need to do some serious consideration.
Versions Available
While the Shure SM58 is only available in three different versions, this microphone is available in four different versions. The major difference between these versions is the accessories that come with it.
What are the versions of Shure PG58 available for sale?
There are four versions of the Shure PG58 available for sale. They are:
1. PG58-QTR
2. PG58-XLR
3. PG58
4. PG58BTS
“What are the versions of Shure PG58 available for sale”
What are the accessories that come with each Shure PG58 version?
The PG58-QTR comes with a 15 feet XLR to ¼ inch cable, a microphone clip, thread adapter, and a carrying pouch. The PG58-XLR comes with a 15 feet XLR to XLR cable, a microphone clip, thread adapter, and a carrying pouch. The PG58 is the most basic version of the four. It only comes with a microphone clip, thread adapter, and a carrying pouch. Lastly, the PG58BTS comes with a tripod stand, an XLR to ¼ inch cable, microphone clip, thread adapter, and a storage bag.
“What are the accessories that come with each Shure PG58 version”
You should note the difference in the cables that come with these two devices. For instance, the first comes with an XLR to ¼ cable, while the second is an XLR to XLR. So you are to choose in line with your needs.
All these versions come with an on/off switch. For people who run podcasts or any other thing that requires self-recording, this device is great. You can easily shut it off without having to reach for your sound system.
On the other hand, if you are a sound engineer, this product comes with its shortcoming. This is considering how someone might mistakenly turn it off, leaving you confused about why the sound is not amplified.
Below is a useful video reviewing the Shure PG58 microphone.
Video: Shure PG58 Microphone Review
What are the Features Unique to the Shure SM58?
The renowned SM58 has its uniqueness in the measure of frequency response, impedance, and versions available. The Frequency is set at about 50 – 15,000 hertz, the impedance at 150 ohms, and has 3 versions.
“What are the Features Unique to the Shure SM58”
Frequency Response – 50 – 15,000 (Hertz)
Compared to the PG58, this microphone is able to pick up a few lower frequencies. So, if you want to record sounds at really low frequencies, then this is the better mic of the two.
Impedance — 150 Ohms
Most people think an impedance lower than 200 Ohms is ideal for a professional microphone. Thankfully, this microphone fits perfectly into the picture. So, if you’re going to be wiring with a very long cable, you have nothing to be bothered about. This is because none of your top-end crispiness will go away.
Versions Available
What are the versions of Shure SM58 available for sale?
There are 3 versions of the Shure SM58 available for sale. They are:
1. SM58-LC
2. SM58-CN
3. SM58S
“What are the versions of Shure SM58 available for sale”
What are the accessories that come with each Shure SM58 version?
The SM58-LC comes with just a stand adapter and a carrying pouch. It’s the most basic and affordable of the three. The SM58-CN comes with a 25 feet XLR Male to XLR Female Cable, a swivel adapter, and a carrying pouch. Lastly, the SM58S comes with an integrated on/off switch, a swivel adapter, and a carrying pouch.
“What are the accessories that come with each Shure SM58 version”
As observed from the description above, only the SM58S comes with an on/off switch.
To know more about this microphone, below is a video reviewing the Shure SM58.
Video: Shure SM58 Dynamic Mic Review / Test
Shure PG58 Vs SM58 – Unique Pros
What are the Advantages of the Shure PG58?
The advantages of the Shure PG58 includes the following.
1. For people who like the on/off switch, it’s good that this is available in every version.
2. The Shure PG58 comes in 4 different versions. This means you get a variety of options to choose from. This is one more than you get with the SM58.
3. In terms of tone, it has a bright mid-range with a bit more presence compared to the SM58. So, you’ll need less EQ to get this sounding well in the mid-range.
4. It’s more affordable.
“What are the Advantages of the Shure PG58”
What are the Advantages of the Shure SM58?
1. It is lightweight compared to the Shure PG58.
2. Compared to the PG58, this microphone has a bit more clarity.
3. With a wider frequency range, you get more sound input with this microphone.
4. The noise handling feature of this microphone is impressive. The SM58 pick up less handling noise compared to the PG58.
“What are the Advantages of the Shure SM58”
Shure PG58 Vs SM58 – Unique Cons
What are the Flaws of the Shure PG58?
The flaws of the Shure PG58 include the following.
1. It has a lot of handling noise.
2. There are no versions without the on/off switch. Because it is not best suited for everyone, this can turnout a disadvantage.
3. It’s slightly heavier than the SM58.
“What are the Flaws of the Shure PG58”
What are the Flaws of the Shure SM58?
The flaws of the Shure SM58 include the following.
1. Especially compared to the Shure PG58, it’s more expensive.
2. It’s only available in 3 versions.
3. To get a bright mid-range, you need to EQ the sound of this microphone.
“What are the Flaws of the Shure SM58”
What are the common advantages of the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58?
Shure PG58 | Shure SM58 | |
| They’re both dynamic microphones | First, both devices are significantly more affordable than condenser microphones. Unlike a condenser microphone, you do not have to buy a phantom power to get the best output. With these microphones, it’s as simple as plug and play. Second, the build quality of both dynamic microphones is simply superb. They are usually solid and very durable. The output of these microphones is not as loud as condenser microphones. As a result, they are great for loud sounds from instruments and vocals. | Same as the Shure PG58. |
| They’re both great sounding microphones. | After much testing, we cannot help but agree that these two sound good. | Same as the Shure PG58. |
| Good connectivity features | As things are, the XLR has become synonymous with connectivity for dynamic microphones. You probably have a bunch of these lying around, which is great for these microphones. | Same as the Shure PG58. |
| The cardioid polar pattern is great | Both microphones come with a cardioid polar pattern which is quite impressive. The well constructed polar pattern is able to effectively pickup the sounds of two or three singers. | Same as the Shure PG58. |
Shure PG58 Vs SM58 – Common Cons
Shure PG58 | Shure SM58 | |
| They can sound muddy | If you’re trying to record something very quiet, the output can be quite muddy with this microphone. Compared to the SM58 in this regard, this microphone is below par because of the handling noise it produces. | The same applies here, although it’s not as bad as the PG58. This is because it doesn’t produce too much handling noise. |
What Do People Think About the Shure PG58 and Shure SM58?
Shure PG58 | Shure SM58 |
| People who bought this microphone attest to its quality. This is more surprising because of the price. Some people did explain how a little bit of EQ would make it sound no less than the SM58. This speaks volumes of its quality. | Shure SM58 is one of the most popular microphones. People appreciate that this microphone is durable. Some sources claim that one of these microphones can last you a whole career. |
| Coming straight out of the box, people have noticed the PG58 is slightly heavier than the SM58. Aside from this, there is so much similarity in the look and feel of these microphones. Although it is often believed the SM58 is more durable than the PG58, there is little to prove this. This is because both microphones are very durable. | Many people attest to the impressive sound quality of this microphone. According to them, it has a clear sounds with good enough low-end and top-end. As observed by people, one flaw that is noticed, is the lack of mid-tones. However, this can be easily EQ’d and is not such a big deal. |
| As observed by experienced users, this microphone has a lot of handling noise. So, potential clients are advised to check out for this. | As regards the on/off switch, people love that this microphone leaves you with options. You can either purchase a product that has this feature or not. This is great considering that some users like the on/off switch, while others do not. |
What Do We Think of the Shure PG58 Vs SM58?
The SM58 is better than the PG58. If you can afford the SM58, then you should certainly go for it. However, if you cannot, the PG58 is not a bad choice. In fact, it’s a better economic decision. This is because it costs about half the price of the SM58, but performs better than that price.
“Which is the better microphone: PG58 versus SM58”
Both microphones are great. However, judging from the difference in price, you may be asking if the SM58 is worth so much more than the PG58.
When this inquiry was made, Shure explained that the PG is an “entry-level series”, while the SM is a “mid-level series”. This is something we agree with.
The Shure SM58 has better frequency response, polar response, and does much better with handling. However, these features are not primary if you’re seeking for a podcast or karaoke mic.
Shure PG58 Vs SM58 – Frequently Asked Questions
How Can You Tell a Fake SM58 Shure?
To tell if an SM58 is fake, you should check out the weight. The original product is weighty. Many fake products fault this standard. Compared to the original, they are a lot lighter. There are various tests to ascertain the authenticity of any acclaimed Shure product. The greatest test is the sound produced. If it does not sound like Shure, then it is not Shure. Another way to find out is by opening the top cap of the product. Some fake producers try to scare you away from checking the inside of the product. They put up a “caution sign” saying that’s a breach in the warranty policy.
Who Uses Shure SM58?
A lot of artists use the Shure SM58. The quality of this renowned microphone is the major reason it is used by many of these artists. Musicians like Paul McCartney, Alice Cooper, Henry Rollins, Martina McBride, G. Love, Roger Daltrey, Cheap Trick, and many others fall into this category.
For many of them, the sound quality especially during live sessions is impressive. This is due to the noise interference that comes with performing in open gatherings. So, if they must perform, using a top-quality microphone is non-negotiable.
What Is a Shure SM58 Used for?
The Shure SM58 is best for live performances. The constant echoes and bad acoustic setting in many of these open areas require the use of a good microphone. The Shure SM58 is great at dealing with the noise problems that come with live performances. It has an inbuilt pop filter that aids its ability to perform effectively.
This is the reason many performers frequently use this product. Other than for live performances, the Shure SM58 is also great for all kinds of vocals and studio works.
Which Is Better: Shure SM57 or SM58?
The Shure SM58 and Shure SM57 are originally designed for different purposes. One of the ways to know this is with the grille size. Shure SM58 has a larger size compared to the SM57 version. Because of the bigger grille size of the SM58 version, it is better suited for vocals of all kinds. On the contrary, the SM57 version is better as a microphone for instruments. It can effectively amplify the sound produced by loud-sounding instruments such as the drums.
So, it is better to use them exactly for the factory’s intended purpose. The SM57 for instruments and SM58 for vocals.
Can You Mic a Guitar Amp with a Shure SM58?
You can use a Shure SM58 to mic your guitar. The Shure SM58 is not the best option when you need to mic any instrument. The SM57 is best suited for this purpose. Both the SM57 and SM58 are manufactured by the renowned Shure brand and share many similarities. However, the major difference is the grille size. The SM58 has a bigger size than the SM57. As a result, the smaller sized grille, SM57, is the better option when you need to mic a guitar or any other instrument.
What Is the Difference Between Shure Sm58 And Beta58?
The difference between the SM58 and Beta58 is the variance in polar patterns. The SM58 has a polar pattern that is apple-shaped. This is also known as cardioid. On the contrary, the Beta58 polar pattern is super-cardioid. Other than peculiarities in polar pattern, there are differences in grill shape, sound output, and noise filtration mechanism. For sound output, the SM58 is less sensitive than the Beta58.
Depending on the use, this can be advantageous or otherwise. If you are aiming to reduce breathing irregularities while singing, the Beta58 may not be so helpful.
Check out these other in-depth articles/reviews…
